On walks, I don't want him to yank my arm in every direction, mark everything, or generally just to think that he calls the shots, but I do want him to enjoy himself. Telling him, “ go see! ” and having him respond by smelling some sweet peemail and looking back at me with pure happiness while he’s kicking his own pee smell around a patch of grass, is pretty heartwarming. It’s an absurd little interaction but I like to think that it strengthens our bond - it's also a good functional reward for a well-behaved pupper. I read a number of of books, most noteably, Inside of a Dog , by Alexandra Horowitz, and The Other End of The Leash by Patricia McConnell, that explain how important the olfactory world is to dogs and the importance of letting your dog enjoy being a dog. Pierre is extremely scent driven, I assume it's because he has some kind of setter or spaniel in him, so I definitely think it would be cruel to force him to ignore the wonderful world around him. I e...